I Photographed Her Parents as They Were Sentenced for Her Twinβs Death. Years Later, I Photographed Her Life.

About eight years ago, I was assigned to photograph the sentencing of Travis and Sarah Mitchell, a couple with deep roots in an insular faith-healing sect outside of Portland, Oregon.Β Β
The Mitchells, as members of the Followers of Christ, adhere to a doctrine that forbids medical care. Instead, followers rely on healing through faith. So when Sarah Mitchell gave birth prematurely to twins in 2017 β and both gasped for breath in their first hours β the couple didnβt rush them to an emergency room. Instead, they turned to prayer.Β
One twin, Ginnifer, lived for four hours, each one a struggle. The family eventually sought medical care for her surviving twin sister, Evelyn, but only after the countyβs deputy medical examiner arrived at the location of the home birth and learned, though not right away, of Evelynβs existence. Even then, he had to seek help from police, who arrived at the Oregon City home and told reluctant family members to take the struggling infant to the hospital or theyβd do it themselves.Β
The Mitchells pleaded guilty to criminally negligent homicide in the death of their infant daughter, Ginnifer, and to criminal mistreatment for failing to seek medical care for her surviving twin, Evelyn. The coupleβs lawyer told the judge that the Mitchells grieved the loss of Ginnifer and loved Evelyn. βTravis and Sarah are utterly sincere, decent and caring human beings,β he told the judge. (The Mitchells and their lawyer did not respond to ProPublica and The Oregonianβs recent requests to be interviewed.)
Today, my memory of the sentencing is more montage than detail. But I remember the crowded gallery, the couple in black-and-white-striped prison clothing, and their prison sentence of more than six years. Evelyn, who within days of her birth had been placed in the custody of Marshall and Jennifer Phillips, another couple in the Followers of Christ, wasnβt present. She remained in the coupleβs permanent care.
The Mitchells went off to prison, and I went on with my life.Β
Such is the grinding rhythm of the daily news cycle. So often I see people on their worst day β and then never again. Stories donβt really end, of course, but my role as a photojournalist is limited. Iβm an observer rather than a participant, seeing mostly slivers of the human experience that offer only a window into the whole. Itβs rare that I get to see what happens next.
Never would I have dreamed that the surviving baby in this case, Evelyn, would be someone Iβd later come to know and care about through my work. But thatβs precisely what happened eight years after that courtroom scene played out, when I began documenting the lives of Evelyn and her parents, the Phillipses. (In a legal filing in an ongoing case relating to Evelynβs custody, the Mitchells criticized the Phillipses for allowing her to participate in our coverage.) The resulting story, a collaboration between ProPublica and The Oregonian, is one of several recently published about faith healing and the Followers of Christ church. It intimately explores the Phillipsesβ journey out of the sect and illustrates how changes in Oregon state law β in contrast to neighboring Idaho, where the Followers have a handful of churches β have led to a reduction in child deaths.Β
To spend time around 9-year-old Evelyn is to behold a luminous, magnetic force of nature. Itβs impossible to imagine this same girl as a premature baby so small that the only items that fit her were doll clothes purchased from the supermarket toy aisle.Β
For months, as I documented Evelynβs life β from her baptism to her home life to doctorsβ appointments β my journalism colleagues worked on their own pieces of our project. Teresa Mahoney, video editor at The Oregonian, produced a video introduction to the story that included a sequence of footage recorded by body cameras worn by police officers who stood outside Evelynβs grandparentsβ house that night, at first nudging, then ordering, Evelynβs family to get her to the hospital. Each time I viewed it, as I watched the officers politely letting time slip away, Iβd need to regulate my own breathing as I imagined Evelyn on the other side of that door, struggling to breathe herself.
I hope that reporter Noelle Crombieβs words, Teresaβs video and my photographs allow readers to see not only the journey of the couple who are raising Evelyn as their own but also the surviving β indeed, thriving β twin I came to know. That Evelyn is alive at all is, depending on your worldview, a miracle.Β
My work is all about observing and capturing moments, about freezing time. Here, I was witnessing the unfolding of time. I got to see what happened next.









The post I Photographed Her Parents as They Were Sentenced for Her Twinβs Death. Years Later, I Photographed Her Life. appeared first on ProPublica.
Check this story
Ask the AI guide
The guide explains what to check and where. It cannot see this article or recent news.
Is this AI-made?
AI checkers give a likelihood, not proof.